Trek Roscoe 7 and 8 Compared: Which One to Choose?

Cyclists Hub is supported by its readers. We may receive a commission if you buy products using our links.
All content on Cyclists Hub is written by humans, not robots. Learn More

I’ll help you navigate the Trek Roscoe mountain bike family in this article by comparing the Roscoe 7 and 8, Gen 3 vs. Gen 4. You’ll learn about the differences between each model, who they are best suited for, and more. 

Plus, I’ll tell you which model gives you the best value for your money to help make your decision easier.

Trek Roscoe Gen 3 vs. Gen 4 and Model Comparison

The main differences between the Roscoe Gen 3 and Gen 4 are the upgraded frame material, increased fork travel from 140 mm to 150 mm, and improved dropper post compatibility due to a shorter and straighter seat tube. The Gen 4 models also feature steeper effective seat tube angles for better pedaling efficiency and a lower standover height.

In addition, a model-specific bolt-on frame bag, and the use of ZS headset cups allowing for geometry adjustments, internal cable routing with a fully guided dropper tunnel, and a model-specific bolt-on frame bag for storage, all while maintaining compatibility with 29″ wheels (27.5″ on the small frame) and supporting tires up to 2.6″ wide.

The following table summarizes the main differences between all Roscoes that belong to the Trek hardtail mountain bikes.

Roscoe Pros & Cons Summary

I summarized the pros & cons of the Roscoe series below.

Roscoe Main Features

Let me now explain the most important features of the Trek Roscoe bikes.

Frame and Geometry

Roscoe Gen 3 have the same aluminum hardtail trail frame, available in XS-XL sizes and many colors that vary between models. Gen 4 have an improved aluminum frame available in S-XL sizes.

The frames have trail geometry, which means a slack head angle and a longer wheelbase for added stability in technical terrain. Gen 4 frames have steeper effective seat tube angles for better pedaling efficiency and a lower standover height, and can use forks with up to 150mm travel (unlike up to 140mm travel on Gen 3).

However, this geometry makes it less suitable for pedaling uphill than Marlin bikes. But don’t worry. It still climbs well.

Suspension

Roscoe mountain bikes have longer suspension travel ranging from 140mm to 150mm (depending on the generation), making riding on technical trails easier.

All Roscoe bikes come with a suspension lockout feature. You can lock the suspension when riding smooth surfaces to reduce energy loss when pedaling.

Wheels and Tires

The wheel size is 27.5-inch for S-size frames. The other sizes use 29-inch wheels, which offer extra stability compared to 27.5-inch wheels.

All Roscoe models have the same rims, which are the Bontrager Line Comp 30 rims. These rims are tubeless-ready.

The Roscoe models come with Bontrager tires that vary in width from 2.4 to 2.6 inches, providing enough grip and comfort on rough or loose surfaces.

Groupset

The groupset is one of the main areas where the different Roscoe models vary, and it’s likely the deciding factor for many people.

The primary difference between them is the number of gears. Fortunately, all Roscoe bikes have a modern 1X drivetrain.

1X drivetrains are popular because they are easy to maintain and shift, and lighter than 2X or 3X groupsets. However, they have fewer gears, so you may not always find the ideal one for your preferred cadence.

The Roscoe 7 Gen 4 has only 10 gears, while the higher-end models have 12. The groupsets range from Shimano CUES, through Shimano Deore, up to SRAM NX Eagle.

It’s up to you and your preferences to decide which one you choose. As a beginner, you probably won’t notice much difference in shifting speed and reliability.

Brakes

Another difference between the Roscoe models is their brakes. The higher-end models use more powerful, 4-piston brakes instead of the standard, 2-piston ones.

If you like to push your bike to the limits or are a heavier rider, you will appreciate the additional stopping power provided by the 4-piston brakes. This is achieved by larger brake pads and a larger braking area.

Extras

All Roscoe bikes come with a dropper post, which is especially useful on trails and descents where the saddle can obstruct you. With the dropper post, you can easily lower it (and subsequently raise it for more comfortable pedaling).

Roscoe bikes also have partially internally routed cables to improve their appearance and internal cable guides to prevent rattling inside the frame.

The frame also has a double-sided chainstay guard and a downtube guard for protection on rough terrain.

Roscoe frames also have mounts for kickstands and racks, making it easy to install these accessories.

You can also use a Blendr stem, which is a mechanism that allows you to easily attach Bontrager’s accessories like lights, speedometers, or bike computers.

Lastly, Roscoe bikes come with lock-on grips that are easier to install and replace than slip-on grips, and the Gen 4 model includes a frame storage bag.

My Verdict

So, which bike from the Roscoe family is the best?

In my opinion, the Roscoe 8 Gen 3 provides the best value for the money. It features 4-piston disc brakes and an SRAM NX Eagle groupset, two significant upgrades compared to the Roscoe 7. Eventually, you can consider the Roscoe 7 Gen 4 if you prefer the updated geometry.

Trek Roscoe FAQ