This article explains whether it is better to spend your money on aluminum, carbon, steel, or even titanium bike.
I describe the benefits and disadvantages of these materials and answer the most frequently asked questions.
Let’s dive in.
Pros and Cons of Bike Frame Materials
The following table shows the summary of the advantages and disadvantages of materials used for bike frames.
• Relatively lightweight
|• Not as stiff as carbon
• Not as durable as other materials
• Not easily repairable
• May corrode over time
• Worse riding quality than other materials
• Very stiff
• Very durable
• Allows creating unique shapes
|• More expensive than aluminum
• Difficult to repair
• Requires more in-depth inspection after crash
• Easy to repair
• Unique appearance (thin round tubes)
|• Not as stiff as carbon
• Higher weight than other materials
• Can be relatively cheap or very expensive
• May corrode over time
|Titanium||• Very durable|
• Corrosion resistant
• Unique appearance (thin round tubes with unique finish)
• Thin round tubes
|• Higher weight than carbon
• Very expensive
You learn more about individual materials below.
The first, widely available aluminum bicycles started to appear in the 70s of the 20th century (source). Aluminum is lighter than steel, so manufacturers could manufacture more lightweight bikes that don’t lack stiffness.
Aluminum is also a relatively cheap material, so it is perfect for mass production. Thanks to its properties, it is not as labor-intensive as carbon or titanium. This means its final price is much lower.
It has a good strength-to-weight ratio (source), resulting in a light and relatively stiff frame.
The main downsides of aluminum frames are that they can’t absorb vibrations and are rigid. Their riding quality is the worst of all materials.
Aluminum (like steel) can corrode over time in humid environments, and it is also not easily repairable (as carbon or steel frames).
The world’s first full carbon road bike was developed and manufactured by Kestrel in 1987 (source). Nowadays, carbon fiber bikes are one of the most popular. Based on my research, around 80% of road bikes of major brands are made of carbon.
There are several reasons for carbon fiber’s popularity. It has a higher strength-to-weight ratio than aluminum, steel, or titanium (source). This results in a lighter, stiffer, and more responsive bike.
Carbon frames can also absorb minor vibrations contributing to better riding comfort.
Another benefit of carbon fiber is that it allows designers and manufacturers to design unique shapes. In the infinite run for aero gains, it is no wonder carbon is the go-to material for performance-oriented bikes road bikes.
On the other hand, carbon is more labor-intensive and more expensive. This reflects in the bike’s final price.
If you crash with a carbon bike, it is recommended to take it to a professional to inspect internal cracks that may cause frame failure.
Leaving aside the first bicycles made of wood, steel was the main material for the production of bike frames since the late 1800s (source) until the 1970s when aluminum bikes started to gaining momentum (source).
Steel is still heavily used today, especially thanks to its relatively low price* and good durability.
*Made-to-order steel frames are much more expensive than mass-produced high-end frames.
Fans of steel praise its riding quality that is better than on aluminum frames. Steel can better absorb vibrations and is more comfortable.
Another popular feature of steel frames is their appearance. Their tubes are thin and round, very similar to titanium bikes. Steel frames are also relatively easy to repair.
The biggest disadvantage of steel frames is their higher weight than other materials. Steel bikes tend to be the heaviest of all materials described in this article.
Although steel is durable, it can corrode over time in wet and humid environments.
According to BikeRadar, titanium bike frames started to be popular in the 1990s. Titanium was (and still is) perceived as a high-end and exclusive material.
Titanium is reactive with oxygen when welding, so titanium bike manufacturers have to employ skillful workers (especially the welders) and have special equipment to tackle this challenge.
But, once the titanium frame (or a complete bike) is finished, you get a unique combination of features like excellent durability & longevity, great stiffness, sleek appearance, and exclusivity.
Titanium bikes have (like steel bikes) thin round tubes, but often raw titanium finish. People often opt for titanium, especially due to its unique design.
The main downsides of titanium frames are the price and higher weight than carbon frames.
NOTE: When buying a titanium bike, you will hear arguments like: “Titanium bikes are buttery smooth.” As an engineer Peak Torque explains in his video, this is not true. Titanium bikes are not more comfortable than aluminum bikes, for example.
He further explains: “Comfort that comes from stiffness is governed by two things Young’s modulus [E] and second moment of area [I].” Young’s modulus of titanium and aluminum is almost the same. So if you have a bike frame that is similarly shaped and weights the same, you also get the same stiffness and, therefore, comfort. I recommend watching the following video to learn more.
Bike Frame Materials FAQ
If you plan to buy a new bike, but you don’t know what material to choose, ask yourself the following questions:
- What is your budget?
- What type of bike do you want? This guide on how to choose a bike may help you.
- Do you prefer stiffness, weight, riding comfort, or design?
Low-end steel bikes are also very affordable and durable but heavy. High-end steel bikes are more expensive and lighter (but not lighter than other materials).
Carbon bikes are perfect for advanced riders and pros. They will provide you with great riding comfort, stiffness, and low weight. The main downside of carbon bikes is their higher price.
Titanium bikes are suitable for people who know what they want. They are expensive, but their exclusivity, durability, and longevity are worth the price.